Skip to main content

Table 2 Selection of reproductive modes according to soil water level

From: The optimal balance between sexual and asexual reproduction in variable environments: a systematic review

Species

Life historical strategy

Response of reproductive propagules according to soil water level (when soil water lever is increased)

Estimates by plant size covariance

Main habitat

References

  

Sexual propagules

Asexual propagules

   

Silene latifolia

Perennial plant

Increased

 

Not used

Open disturbed habitats like fallow fields, field margins, and roadsides

(Gehring and Linhart 1993)

Cyperus esculentus

Pseudoannual

Decreased

Increased (But not one clone)

Not used

Moist fields, in heavily irrigated crops, along riverbanks and roadsides, and in ditches

(Li et al. 2001b)

Lythrum salicaria

Perennial plant

Decreased

 

Not used

Wetlands

(Mal and Lovett-Doust 2005)

B. carinatus

Perennial plants with chasmogamy and cleistogamy

Increased

Decreased

Not used

Forest

(Harlan 1945)

Stipa leucotrich

Perennial plants with chasmogamy and cleistogamy

Increased

Decreased

Not used

Grasslands, prairies, and brushy areas

(Brown 1952)

Dichanthelium clandestinum

Perennial plants with chasmogamy and cleistogamy

N.S (CH mass/CL mass: increased)

Decreased (But one population on one variable: N.S)

Not used

Open or frequently disturbed and early successional habitats

(Bell and Quinn 1987; Cheplick 2007)

Calathea micans

Perennial plants with chasmogamy and cleistogamy

(Many rainfall): increased

(Many rainfall): N.S

Not used (CH: positively correlated with plant size)

Lowland tropical rain forests

(Corff 1993)

Bromus unioloides

Annual plants with chasmogamy and cleistogamy

Increased (when only short photoperiods)

 

Statistical method not reported

Prairie

(Langer and Wilson 1965)

Impatiens capensis

Annual plants with chasmogamy and cleistogamy

Increased (not with covariates)

N.S

Used (CH: positively correlated with plant size, CL: independent of plant size)

Floodplains

(Waller 1980)

N.S (with covariates)

Collomia grandiflora

Annual plants with chasmogamy and cleistogamy

Increased

Decreased

Used

Disturbed and open sites within or immediately adjacent to forest and shrub communities.

(Minter and Lord 1983; Wilken 1982)

Gymnarrhena micrantha

Amphicarpic annual plant

(Many rainfall): increased

(Low soil moisture): increased

Statistical method not reported

Steppe and desert regions

(Koller and Roth 1964)

Amphicarpaea bracteata L.

Amphicarpic annual plant

(Many rainfall): N.S

(Many rainfall): increased

Not used (CH: positively correlated with plant size, CL: positively correlated with plant size, not in 1983)

Moist woods

(Trapp and Hendrix 1988)

Polygonum thunbergii

Amphicarpic annual plant

N.S

N.S

Not used (CH: positively correlated with plant size)

Riversides

(Kawano et al. 1990)

Commelina benghalensis

Amphicarpic annual plant

More increased

Less increased

Not used

The ditch-banks at the field margins and low areas within a field

(Webster and Grey 2008)

  1. CH chasmogamy, CL cleistogamy, N.S not significantly different